Re: Snape-Lovers. Possible help from an unlikely source.

In the previous message gjw gjw@xxxxxxxxxxx wrote:

> I have been criticizing the numerous "Snape is Good" theories for some
> time now, since most of them rest on the unlikely idea that Snape and
> Dumbledore planned out his death in advance, or that Dumbledore asked
> Snape to kill him.
>
> I've also said that I can't imagine any theory in which Dumbledore is
> actually dead yet Snape remains good.
>

<SNIP>
If the potion were a horcrux then it would have been drunk by RAB (or one
who was with him) and perhaps destroyed... The potion would be gone and DD
would not have had to drink it... Otherwise it would be a perpetual horcrux
potion (which would be wonderful for V)...

So, no, I don't think the potion was the horcrux...

Babs


.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Attn: Snape-Lovers. Possible help from an unlikely source.
    ... >> We've seen from the casual way he threw around his first Horcrux, ... Dumbledore disagrees: "The careless way in which Voldemort regarded ... Snape or drinking the Horcrux/potion), but in general Rowling uses DD ... >> I threw in the part about Snape making the potion because it's a neat ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)
  • Re: Dumbledore asked Snape to kill him
    ... Do you still believe that a non-terminal Dumbledore wanted Snape to ... Dumbledore wanted Snape to kill him... ... The look he gives Harry, whose name has just come out of the Goblet, ... will prevent me taking the Horcrux. ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)
  • Re: The Real Horcrux revealed -- SPOILER WARNING
    ... re - the potion being a horcrux... ... >> When I read the scene in which Snape killed Dumbledore, ... the green potion was the real horcrux. ... >> Dumbledore wanted to see only Snape when he and Harry got back to ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)
  • Re: Anyone care to argue Snapes guilt or innocence?
    ... >>>I think I'll open a thread on that potion... ... I have been criticizing the numerous "Snape is Good" theories for some ... Dumbledore planned out his death in advance, ... Dumbledore to kill him. ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)
  • Re: The Real Horcrux -- SPOILER WARNING
    ... >>When I read the scene in which Snape killed Dumbledore, ... >>Dumbledore knew that the potion was the horcrux before he drank it. ... >>told Harry that the potion wouldn't kill him, ...
    (soc.singles.moderated)