Re: The Identity of R.A.B.--My Speculation

gjw <gjw@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
: On 5 Sep 2005 21:00:19 GMT, Troels Forchhammer
: <Troels@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
:
:>My point, however, is precisely that it is pointless to even attempt
:>to squeeze the events down into a specific time-line, and that while
:>doing so will make it easier for people to keep track, it also
:>invites conclusions based on coincidences that depend on a
:>consistency that doesn't, IMO, exist.
:
:
: I agree. I've always seen the HP world as existing in a relatively
: timeless "now". Naturally, it has its own internal time frame (e.g.
: Hagrid was born before Harry, Merlin existed before Hagrid, etc.), but
: I suspect that Rowling meant the books to simply happen in "the
: present", whenever that happens to be for the reader. Attempts to tie
: them to a "real" present, an actual Muggle date, is a mistake, IMO.
: With the exception of the mention of the video game (something she
: probably now regrets), JKR has done a good job of keeping actual
: modern dates out of her Potterverse. When, 20 or 50 years from now,
: someone reads the books, I assume they too will imagine them as
: happening "now", not back in the 1990's.

The more time passes the less credible that will be,though.

I prefer explicit chronologies.

-=-=-
The World Trade Center towers MUST rise again,
at least as tall as before...or terror has triumphed.
.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: The Identity of R.A.B.--My Speculation
    ... >to squeeze the events down into a specific time-line, ... Hagrid was born before Harry, Merlin existed before Hagrid, etc.), but ... I suspect that Rowling meant the books to simply happen in "the ... them to a "real" present, an actual Muggle date, is a mistake, IMO. ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)
  • Re: Who are the two you think will die... and WHY??
    ... My god but you're ruthless:-P ... I like Hagrid ... More often than not it is Harry who has to save Hagrid's neck, ... I read the books, but it works not through subtlety or literary skill, ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)
  • Re: What Should I Read in 2008? (Long List, With Voting)
    ... of Usenet what books I should read this year. ... This is, IMO, very good indeed. ... Not IM De Camps very best, but worth reading. ... Lots of fun. ...
    (rec.arts.sf.written)
  • Re: Boswell: Structuralist or Post-Structualist?
    ... Especially since he wants us to focus on books that have a ... likes, dislikes, romantic notions and personal prejudices (which we all have, ... quality and depth, almost all written from some pro- or anti- preconceived ... Your prof. is asking a lot IMO, but at least set an interesting task... ...
    (soc.history.medieval)
  • Re: Remember my last!
    ... I'm reading through the books again whilst waiting ... Harry says yes and then there is this paragraph. ... I don't recall Hagrid mentioning to the Dursleys that Voldemort was ... seem to remember that the first time Hagrid mentions Voldemort ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)