Re: Snape is good???
>>so
>> WHY did Snape NOT TAKE HARRY WITH HIM???
>
> Because then Snape would be the one who killed Dumbledore AND
> captured/immobilized/defeated Harry Potter. The last thing Voldemort
> would want is competition for his followers' fear and respect.
Paul W. Lints Jr. UIN: 25030144
> Valid email: pwlints@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
Look at the lengths you have to go to support the Snape is evil notion.
Would Voldemort object to HP being handed over to him, because it would make
his follower look like competition? Would Grayback or the others have left
Potter behind, fearing Voldemort's reaction to his increased status among
DE's? They weren't given the chance because Snape saved Potter, and went
further by instructing him once again about the importance of occlumency.
BTW, when you use a killfile, don't inform the miscreant, because they can
then post after you and possibly influence the discussion deliberately
without your knowledge. You can't rely on their ramblings being copied by
the next responder.
.
Relevant Pages
- Re: To those who think Snape is evil...
... What did Snape, and other DE's know about him then, though? ... as V's spy.Then in October of 1981, V kills Lily Potter. ... Snape reports it to Voldemort though possibly not ... Both Dumbledore and Voldemort narrow it down ...
(alt.fan.harry-potter) - Re: To those who think Snape is evil...
... What did Snape, and other DE's know about him then, though? ... as V's spy.Then in October of 1981, V kills Lily Potter. ... Snape reports it to Voldemort though possibly not ... Both Dumbledore and Voldemort narrow it down ...
(alt.fan.harry-potter) - Re: I thought Snape was... (SPOILERS for Half-Blood)
... I'm quite new here and thought I'd dare to post after having found out that I might be a Potter addict as I'm just rereading PoA after I read HBP twice in a row. ... I also thought Snape was against Voldemort or at least not the Dark Lord's faithful follower. ... But I do think he has always been rather unfair to Harry and to many other students also. ...
(alt.fan.harry-potter) - Re: When did Snape convert? (was Re: Has anyone compiled a handy list of the arguments for and again
... I'd think that Snape would be more likely to make that third part of the Vow given that he is a loyal Voldemort supporter, than under the complementary hypothesis. ... I have said that I think the act of Snape killing Dumbledore is most appropriately interpreted as strong evidence that Snape lacks a sense of loyalty to Dumbledore. ... I am attempting to discern a pattern in the relationship between Harry, Snape, and Voldemort. ...
(alt.fan.harry-potter) - DEATHLY HALLOWS - Revelations, pt 4 (Chapters 28-32)
... Aberforth Dumbledore - barman at the Hog's Head Inn, ... Current state of Hogwarts: ... Voldemort near the cave entrance at the time of being summoned - ... Showdown between McGonagall & Snape - not unlike the one between ...
(alt.fan.harry-potter) |
|
