Re: Dumbledore's Death Denial Club

stark <at_nihil@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in
7u1Ne.1579$ej5.860@lakeread05:">news:7u1Ne.1579$ej5.860@lakeread05:

> On 2005-08-18, Dave Vanness <dvannessDELETETHIS@xxxxxxxx> wrote:
>> And you still won't answer the question. Supposing DD's death were
>> indeed faked, how would she reference the events at the end of the
>> book? Specifically - what words should she use to reference those
>> events? How could she *not* use the word death? I'm waiting.
>
> I have answered the question multiple times. You simply refuse to
> accept it, even when I showed examples. In cases where she was asked
> direct questions about plot points she wished to hide, she simply
> evaded or refused to answer the question.
>
> She has never lied, and according to her, she has never deliberately
> mislead anyone.
>

And you refused to acknowledge that *none* of the examples you cited
involved her refusing to comment on events that have _already occurred_ and
have been observed by the narrator. Every question you raised involved her
being asked to speculate on things not yet written or not directly
observed. I know the distinction is subtle, but it is important. She'd
have a bloody hard time getting away with not commenting about _any_ of the
events at the end of the HBP and you know it.
.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Size of a reference?
    ... > I got more confused regarding the size of a reference. ... See my reply in alt.comp.lang.learn c-c++ ... Simply add the name of the second newsgroup ... the regulars don't answer the very same question multiple times. ...
    (comp.lang.cpp)
  • Re: Does the file need to be open?
    ... "jtinne" wrote in message ... >> you refuse, you still see the old values. ... >>> When you are using one book as a reference for another book, ...
    (microsoft.public.excel.misc)
  • Re: employment law help
    ... most companies who are dissatisfied with an employee simply ... satisfactory reference from their previous employer. ... Many employers refuse to give references at all. ... Money is the root of all evil; everyone needs roots! ...
    (uk.legal)
  • Re: Does the file need to be open?
    ... If someone else on the network was to have the file open would it update off ... > you open the referencing workbook, it will ask to update links, which you ... > you refuse, you still see the old values. ... >> When you are using one book as a reference for another book, ...
    (microsoft.public.excel.misc)
  • Re: Dumbledores Death Denial Club
    ... > Specifically - what words should she use to reference those events? ... You simply refuse to ... mislead anyone. ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)