Re: Dursleys spoiler
- From: friesian@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx (Meghan Noecker)
- Date: 28 Jul 2005 11:16:31 GMT
On Wed, 27 Jul 2005 12:28:48 GMT, Sky_rider <ozzieboy@xxxxxxxxx>
>On 26 Jul 2005 16:41:08 -0700, "Neener" <NINADSE@xxxxxxx> looked at
>Ron with an evil Grint in his eye and said :
>>> I wonder why she wrote one thing and said another?
>>And see, what I'm saying is that she DIDN'T actually write it, because
>>Figg never confirmed that she SAW what she was attesting to :-)
>>I'm certain that I'm not the only one who was struck by the
>>inconsistency in her answer, because I'm just not that smart.
>And yet I never doubted it for a second... there was no reason for her
>*not* to have felt it their effects if she was close enough...
>...... and how would she have known what Harry was facing had she
>*not* felt the emotions etc??
She *did* feel the dementors. She just didn't *see* them.
In the book, Figg claims to see them but doesn't sound very
believable. And when asked at the end, says that's what happened.
In JKR's quote, she says that Figg didn't see them, but knew enough
about them to recognize what they were. So, she felt the dementors and
knew that's what must have happened.
Meghan & the Zoo Crew
Equine and Pet Photography
- Prev by Date: Re: Major Spoiler-- Location of all seven Horcruxes
- Next by Date: Re: Snape evil or not... proof. (SPOILER!)
- Previous by thread: Re: Dursleys spoiler
- Next by thread: Re: Dursleys spoiler