Re: Plot Holes in Book6

Richard Eney <dicconf@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:
: In article <04df62423cad67d6e8692895826cdd0c@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>,
: danobats <dontemailmecuziwontrespond@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
:><dicconf wrote>
:>>Regulus attended Hogwarts but he was in the Black family and a Slytherin
:>>when Slughorn was there. He was probably in the room during that memory
:>>scene.
:>
:>Regulus= Sirius YOUNGER brother, and Sirius wasnt at Hogwarts anytime near
:>Voldemort and them, so thats not it
:
: Oops, you are completely correct.
:
: Hmm. The Black family seemed to have a lot of dark arts stuff; maybe they
: had a little home schooling in it. Snape learned the unforgivables as a
: teenager.
:
: =Tamar

As far as the memory scene with Slughorn...I noted the claim that
Riddle was by no means the oldest...but he had to be near the end
of his time at Hogwarts at that point...were the founding Death
Eaters all seventh-years?

-=-=-
The World Trade Center towers MUST rise again,
at least as tall as before...or terror has triumphed.
.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: "issues" that should be resolved in book seven?
    ... He was busy before then; by the time he realized he wanted to take over ... Hogwarts, DD was in place. ... Harry will look at DD's ... memory again and there will be some clue that it was tampered with. ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)
  • HBP Chapter 6 re-read
    ... which the Dark Mark terrorists gain access to Hogwarts at the end of ... * Regulus Black "only lasted a few days" after deserting the Death ... he'd have to be to not only fake death at the hands of the D.E. but ... then at the end of the book put one over on Voldemort, ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)