Re: Major Clue or Mistake? (UK versus US)

"Blon Fel Fotch Passameer-Day Slitheen" <bffpds@raxacoricofallapatoria>
wrote in message news:bffpds.57896956184208@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
> Andy Platt wrote:
>
>> Wrong. They are canon. They are in the published books and until we see
>> JKR say, "They made that up, I didn't write it" it's canon.
>
> Not when the Levine version contradicts the rest of the world, such as
> changing the Philosopher's Stone to a dumbed-down "Sorcerer's Stone".

Whether you agree with a change or not is neither here nor there. In this
case JKR suggested the alternative (upon request) herself. It is, therefore,
canon.

Andy.

--
I'm not really here, it's just your warped imagination


.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Major Clue or Mistake? (UK versus US)
    ... > Andy Platt wrote: ... >>> Not when the Levine version contradicts the rest of the world, ... Levine has since said that he regrets making the change. ... And exactly what in all that stops it being canon? ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)
  • Re: Major Clue or Mistake? (UK versus US)
    ... >> Andy Platt wrote: ... >>> And exactly what in all that stops it being canon? ... Prev by Date: ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)
  • Re: Major Clue or Mistake? (UK versus US)
    ... They are canon. ... They are in the published books and until we see ... >> Not when the Levine version contradicts the rest of the world, ... Levine has since said that he regrets making the change. ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)
  • Re: Major Clue or Mistake? (UK versus US)
    ... They are canon. ... They are in the published books and until we see ... > JKR say, "They made that up, I didn't write it" it's canon. ... changing the Philosopher's Stone to a dumbed-down "Sorcerer's Stone". ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)