Re: can I use cl3 memory instead of 2.5 ?



Tom wrote:
Hello
I have a MSI KM400 (KM4M-L) mainboard that currently has one 512mb
module cl2.5 (512MB, DDR, 333, CL2.5) - the other memory I want to put
in is 512mb 400 ddr cl3 184 pin ....

Is it likely to work?
Regards, R

Sure. The computer will likely continue to run at DDR333 speed,
when the new stick is added.

Faster memory can be run at a slower speed.

The BIOS looks at all the parameters, and selects the common
denominator. If it sees a DDR333 and a DDR400 stick, it chooses
to run them at DDR333. (If the BIOS also has "bus loading rules",
it can choose to run the bus even slower, if there are known
problems with a high bus loading. For example, with three double
sided sticks, it may automatically select DDR266 instead. And that
would be based on a loading rule, rather than individual speed
specs.)

The CAS will also be adjusted. Worst case, the BIOS would use
CAS3. Or it may choose to use CAS2.5. The thing is, the CAS
is roughly proportional to speed, so a CAS3 DDR400 (3*5ns = 15ns
CAS), is roughly the same as CAS2.5 DDR333 (2.5 * 6.0ns = 15ns).
So CAS2.5 should be possible, unless the automatic BIOS logic
decides otherwise.

You can verify the SPD table in each DIMM, using this tool.
There could be more than one column in the SPD table, and
that helps the BIOS to decide what common settings would work
with the sticks.

http://www.cpuid.com/cpuz.php

Paul
.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: SDRAM to DDR problem update
    ... Checked with Crucial CAS is 2.5 for PC2100 DDR. ... There you will see a list of BIOS options. ... Near the bottom of the list is one named: SDR/DDR CAS Latency SPD ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.hardware)
  • Re: RAM SPD problem
    ... Today for the first time I ran the CPU-Z utility and found that, although the SPD of one of these RAM modules shows an RAS# to CAS# delay of 3 for both 166MHz and 200MHz, the other's SPD indicates RAS# to CAS# delays of 11 and 13 respectively. ... Also, with the RAM speed set in the BIOS to Auto, the memory is being run at 333MHz. ... "Command Rate" is a setting that affects how the Address/Command bus ... The DIMM has two busses. ...
    (alt.comp.periphs.mainboard.asus)
  • Re: P4P800se and populating all memory slots?
    ... I've tried using 2x512 basic Crucial modules with 2x512 Samsung ... and take me back to the bios screen). ... it ran the memory ... I'd start by looking at the SPD contents. ...
    (alt.comp.periphs.mainboard.asus)
  • Re: ACTUAL RAM SPEED
    ... The CPU-z memory tab shows '166.7 MHz'. ... Depends on whether you have the BIOS use the SPD settings (what the ... be overclocking your 166MHz memory by running it at 200MHz. ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.hardware)
  • Re: SDRAM to DDR problem update
    ... If I alter these settings by turning off Auto,would I then turn off, change to DDR, then try and reboot. ... The cas at moment only shows SPD no number. ... So you have the option of changing the BIOS ... RAS Precharge time 4T. ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.hardware)