Re: Do You Defrag?



pgx@xxxxxxxxxxxx writes:

She is now on a NTFS system. How important is defraging under NTFS.

Not very, unless the file structure is operating close to capacity and
files are constantly being created, deleted, and grown or shrunk.
Servers often meet these criteria, but desktops usually don't.

My knowledge of the structure of the disk under NTFS is almost ZERO.

It's vastly superior to FAT and pretty much damage-proof, but it can
get fragmented if you are using almost all the capacity of your disks
and you modify the structure a lot.

I defrag once in a great while, but since I'm not anywhere close to
capacity on the drives, there usually isn't much fragmentation.

Does defraging make it easier to recover files?

Not really. But NTFS is extremely resistant to file-system
corruption, so losing files that way is unheard of. I've never seen
an NTFS partition become corrupted.

NTFS is also designed such that deleted files cannot be recovered (for
security reasons). The data isn't actually erased (unless you set a
special option that isn't exposed via the user interfaces), but the
design of the file structure is such that it's extraordinarily
difficult to determine where a given file might have been once the
file is deleted. Thus, on NTFS, don't delete a file unless you really
want it gone forever, because you can't just flip a bit to get it
back.

--
Transpose mxsmanic and gmail to reach me by e-mail.
.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Do You Defrag?
    ... get fragmented if you are using almost all the capacity of your disks ... I run an NTFS partition for the PVR, ... file structure is such that it's extraordinarily difficult to determine ... I can need 50G of free space for a particular evening etc. ...
    (alt.comp.hardware.pc-homebuilt)
  • Re: PLEOMAX USBPOWERDRIVE UHD8G from Samsung
    ... You would have to either format the flash drive to NTFS or break up your ... backup into smaller chunks to save it. ... from the capacity 7.42GB. ... Could this be the reason? ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.basics)
  • reinstalling xp question
    ... NTFS is a much better structure than FAT, ... I believe the Quick refers to the format method, ... than a file structure, the normal method is to erase ... NTFS, You won't regret it. ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.general)
  • Re: Corrupt File System
    ... > i have a slave drive, no OS on it just formatted NTFS, only a few months ... > I rebooted and then noticed that the drive label had changed to LOCAL DISK ... > ran seagate disk utilities etc, all reports fine except for the NTFS file ... > is there a way to repair the file structure without losing the data or any ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.help_and_support)
  • Re: Corrupt File System
    ... > i have a slave drive, no OS on it just formatted NTFS, only a few months ... > I rebooted and then noticed that the drive label had changed to LOCAL DISK ... > ran seagate disk utilities etc, all reports fine except for the NTFS file ... > is there a way to repair the file structure without losing the data or any ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.general)